[1998] [1996]

The audience judges the skaters in this competition. Skaters perform only one program and each audience member gives one score. Those scores are averaged together for a one-number final score. In 1998, internet users also scored the competition and the event was not held in 1997.

1998 Great Skate Debate
March 27, 1998 ~ Chicago, Illinois

Ladies
1. Kristi Yamaguchi, Trouble
2. Ekaterina Gordeeva, Three Preludes
3. Rory Burghart, Think
4. Katarina Witt, It's A Man's World
5. Caryn Kadavy, Climb Every Mountain
6. Yuka Sato, That Girl
7. Denise Biellmann, hot pink costume
8. Rosalynn Sumners, Sweet Rosalyn

Men
1. Scott Hamilton, The Show Must Go On (Wizard Of Oz)
2. Paul Wylie, Go The Distance
3. Kurt Browning, Antares
4. Rudy Galindo, In the Navy/Macho Man/YMCA
5. Brian Orser, The Story of My Life
6. Jozef Sabovcik, Slow and Easy

1996 Great Skate Debate
May 7, 1996 ~ Greenbay, Wisconsin

Ladies
1. Yuka Sato, Runaway
2. Denise Biellmann, Lick It
3. Katarina Witt, I'm the Only One
4. Caryn Kadavy, Somewhere
5. Rosalynn Sumners, Remember Me This Way
6. Nancy Kerrigan, I'd Give My Life For You
7. Elizabeth Manley, Are You Ready for This?

Men
1. Scott Hamilton, I Love Me
2. Kurt Browning, That's Entertainment
3. Paul Wylie
4. Viktor Petrenko
5. Jozef Sabovcik
6. Brian Orser
7. Mark Mitchell, Disco medley